Musk Thistle, Nodding Plumeless Thistle
Accepted infraspecific names of Carduus nutans from Plants of the World Online: Carduus nutans subsp. alpicola (Gillot) Chass. & J.Arenes, Carduus nutans subsp. falcatoincurvus P.H.Davis, Carduus nutans subsp. granatensis (Willk.) O.Bolòs & Vigo, Carduus nutans subsp. leiophyllus (Petrovic) Arènes, Carduus nutans var. litoralis P.D.Sell, Carduus nutans subsp. nutans, Carduus nutans subsp. platylepis (Rchb. & Sauter) Nyman, Carduus nutans subsp. platypus (Lange) Greuter, Carduus nutans subsp. siculus (Franco) Greuter, Carduus nutans subsp. trojanus P.H.Davis
Carduus nutans L. is the correct and accepted scientific name for the Musk Thistle. The genus and species were named and described as such by Carl von Linnaeus in the second edition of Species Plantarum in 1753.
Plants of the World Online lists 91 species in the Carduus genus as of 1-24-20 when I am updating this page. That number could change.
The above distribution map from Plants of the World Online, with permission, shows how widespread Carduus nutans has become. Areas shown in green are where it is native and purple shows where it has been introduced. The species could be more widespread than what the map shows.
There are several links at the bottom of the page for further reading.
I first encountered this species growing next to the barn in the summer of 2015. Dad said he had not seen them before and I hadn’t seen them anywhere on the farm since I moved back here in February 2013. He had to buy hay the winter I arrived because he didn’t have enough, so I think the seed had arrived with hay. These thistles were growing in a spot where a bale of hay had been fed during that time.
There are Bull Thistles growing around the pond and in the front pasture which I have been continually working on. The problem is, thistle seeds can lie dormant for 30-50 years so it is a continual battle. Whether you spray or dig, there are always more the following year.
Carduus nutans, like most other thistle species, is a biennial plant. They come up from seed and remain small rosette the first year then flower and go to seed the following season.
The stems are wickedly spiny as are the long lance-shaped, lobed leaves. Definitely not a plant you would want to run into in the dark.
I am not going to give technical botanical terminology for this plant like I do most wildflowers. You can check out some of the links at the bottom of the page written by experts for that.
The flowers are AWESOME, however, and many pollinators adore them.
The flowers are pretty neat as the buds open.
I told dad I would dig them up once they flowered so I could take photos. Besides spraying, I dig down 2-3″ below the soil to cut their taproots. This will kill the plant just as well as spraying. You have to burn the flowers and buds or spray them or they will go to seed… I saw no more of the Musk Thistle until one came up and flowered in another area where no thistles had been before…
BUT… In 2019…
I had started feeding cows for a friend of mine during the fall of 2018 on his farm north of town (not the farm he lived on). When spring arrived, he mentioned he would like for me to spray the thistles there. Well, it was spring and I hadn’t noticed that many yet nor did I know what type of thistles he was talking about. Then, when they started coming up, I could see they were Carduus nutans. At first I thought, “OH WOW! They are the ones with the silvery leaves.” Mind you, I had only experienced very few on my farm…
Next thing I knew they were coming up by the THOUSANDS! I am not an advocate of spraying, and he knew that, but I could tell digging was NOT an option. So, I used 2-4-D. There were a few Bull Thistles (Cirsium vulgare) which I also sprayed and dug at first.
It seemed like it was going to be a never-ending battle! So, I decided to concentrate my early efforts on the Musk Thistles because they flower earlier in the season and the Bull Thistles were just beginning to grow.
While I was out spraying on his farm I noticed several species of wildflowers I didn’t have on my farm. This gave me an opportunity to take more photos and ID more wildflowers.
Once I pretty much had the Musk Thistles pretty well whipped in the front pastures, I went to another part of the farm and there were thousands there as well… GEEZ!
Walking and spraying, walking and spraying… For days and hours on end…
I am running out of words…
I am writing this page on January 26, 2020, when I have time to catch up on writing and updating pages for the blog. Seeing these photographs brings back A LOT of memories…
Then temperatures started getting HOTTER and spraying thistles all summer in the heat was definitely not what I had expected for the summer.
Not only was I spraying the Musk Thistles, but the Bull Thistles were also starting to bud.
So, as I had the Musk Thistles pretty much under control, I had to start spraying and digging the Bull Thistles.
Even though I had sprayed and dug thistles all summer there were a few that went to seed where I hadn’t seen them earlier. Although my friend and I both knew we had made a good stab at eliminating A LOT of flowers that would have gone to seed, they would be back the following spring. Carduus nutans seeds are viable in the ground for up to 50 years…
So, am I going to go through this all again in 2020? Hopefully, I will win the lottery and I can move to a country that has no thistles.
I have enjoyed photographing and learning about the many wildflowers growing on the farm and other areas. I have grown over 500 different plants and most have pages listed on the right side of the blog. I am not an expert, botanist, or horticulturalist. I just like growing, photographing and writing about my experience. I rely on several websites for ID and a horticulturalist I contact if I cannot figure them out. Wildflowers can be somewhat variable from location to location, so sometimes it gets a bit confusing. If you see I have made an error, please let me know so I can correct what I have written.
I hope you found this page useful and be sure to check the links below for more information. They were written by experts and provide much more information. If you can, I would appreciate it if you would click on the “Like” below and leave a comment. It helps us bloggers stay motivated. You can also send an email to me at firstname.lastname@example.org. I would enjoy hearing from you.